We have been learning to use our persuasive writing skills to construct letters to the media about the Rena disaster. We have sent our letters to the Bay of Plenty Times.
Have a read of each others letters.
Have a think about the content of each letter.
What letter stands out for you?
What is the key message in the letter?
Comment on a letter or two and give feedback and feed-forward to the author,
using the success criteria as a guide.
THE FOLLOWING LETTERS ARE FROM:
Tall Poppies
Room 9
Tauriko School
SH 29
RD1
Tauranga 3112
Dear Editor
Look at what has happened all because one silly captain decided to take a shortcut. One silly action has caused many things to happen - beaches turned black, hazardous containers sitting on a ship that is about to break in half, and the lives of many birds lost!
Why is this happening!?
The pictures I have seen are appalling! They disgust me - all that wildlife suffering in over 300 tonnes of oil! For all we know it could be like being thrown around in a cooking pot!
And what will happen to all those goods just floating around? I have heard that there are meat products in some of the containers. Could they turn the water stagnant? And what about all those containers full of chemicals? Are they underneath 200 more containers, where it will take a long time to get them all off? Will the ship crack and spill out dangerous containers like a split sack?
What I am asking is: will we run out of time?
We can only wait for the answer to these questions.
Yours sincerely
Bella
Dear Editor,
All of the oil has been transferred off the Rena now-that’s great - but what about the containers? What about all the hazardous gases in them? Just think about how much more damage could be done to our beautiful beaches with all the containers falling off or sinking down to the bottom of the ocean.
At least 88 containers have fallen off the Rena so far; we are just so lucky that most of those have had no hazardous gases in them. What about all the other 1368, especially the one that supposedly has hydrogen in it, which, it has been said, when the packages inside make contact with water, will explode! Imagine how much more wildlife could die or lose their homes.
Not only could the containers damage the sea, but think how much weight they are putting on the ship. Since they have completed the number one priority (getting the oil off) it is essential that they do their best to get the containers off. I understand that they are bolted in, but they got on board to transfer oil off, so why can’t they unbolt them one at a time?
Remember on the news a couple of weeks ago when a family that had moved from Christchurch pointed out that their belongings were on the ship in a container. Lots of valuable belongings could be lost along with that family’s.
We all know that this was one foolish mistake that nobody wanted to happen, but it did and we can’t change that. But we can at least try to save the containers and wildlife.
Kind regards
Jerushah
Dear Editor,
I think the salvors are doing a fantastic job recovering the oil from the grounded vessel, Rena.
They are working in really dangerous conditions such as storms, waves, high winds, fumes and with a ship that is slowly breaking up around them.
This, New Zealand’s largest maritime disaster – may have been avoided. The main question is… “Who is at fault”? Is it the owners, the captain, the crew, or the charter company (M.S.C)?
(I’m sure this will come out in the inquiry as two of the main suspects have been arrested.)
It’s so disappointing and dangerous that containers are just floating around in the ocean. And what about the ones that have sunk or even the ones that got into the shipping channel and have semi submerged? What is being done and can they do anything about it?
I have heard that in some containers there are dangerous goods inside, and when in contact with water may explode. What about those containers? Are they still on board? If so, will they get them off quickly enough?
Having said that, there is a massive barge called ST60 coming here from Singapore that can get the containers off the Rena.
They won’t do this until all the oil is off, but the barge isn’t due for another 3 weeks.
Should the barge, crane and salvors be able to do their work, there will be a lot of happy people finally getting to see their belongings and stock again.
All this is only possible if the Rena doesn’t break in half during the next storm – which is highly likely.
So fingers crossed and we hope for the best.
Yours sincerely
Edyn
Dear Editor
Thick oil, valuable containers, forbidden Rena. In my opinion this disaster is horrible.
There is a large amount of oil leaking from the ship and it’s polluting our precious seas. Not only is it polluting our seas, it is killing sea creatures. There have been over 300 sea creatures found completely covered in oil.
The person in control should face serious consequences because they say they were arriving late into port so they took a short cut and got stranded. Come on - this is not good enough! Not only did they attempt a short cut, they were celebrating the captain’s birthday. Drinking? They might not have got stuck if they had the depth reader on. The depth reader is what tells them how deep the water is but it’s no use if they didn’t even have it on!
This has had a huge effect on us. NZ has had a year of disasters –Christchurch, Pike River, a natural gas leak which brought business to a halt. We cannot afford the Rena oil spill - who is going to pay for it! There are containers falling off with all sorts of things in them like $500,000 dream cars, highly flammable liquids and even meat patties. Do the Singaporeans or the Greek owners have insurance? Well, to date they haven’t given us the money we need and it’s all their fault!
New Zealanders are very upset and traumatized about the outcomes of this grounding. All you ship captains out there must not let this happen again.
Yours sincerely
Joel
Dear Editor
Birds’ and fishes’ lives are being destroyed, our beaches are turning black and now oil is making its way to Mayor Island. What are we going to do? We can’t use chemicals, but we can’t let our native birds die.
An expected ten tonnes of oil is making its way to the coast line of Mayor Island. There are over fifteen types of native birds on Mayor Island, including the pied shag which dives for fish and it will be covered in oil. How are we going to clean up Mayor Island without further damage to the environment?
I want to find a way to help the wild life without hurting them more, but for the moment all the locals can help out, by scrubbing the rocks and picking up oil from the beach.
Yours sincerely
Kate
Dear Media
How are we supposed to sleep at night knowing that this tragedy is happening? Yes, I’m talking about THE RENA OIL SPILL. It is a mystery how the Rena ended up on the Astrolabe Reef and why was it so far off course? There are many rumours about what happened but we need to wait and see what the judge says.
Why isn’t the reef marked so ships know it is there? Regardless, the person who is responsible for the Rena grounding should step up and say it was their fault. I am absolutely disgusted how our waters are being treated - the people who caused it probably don’t even care that we have a mass oil spill.
To make it worse, eighty-eight containers have fallen off the Rena and some of the objects in the containers, if in contact with water, can be highly dangerous. Also some of the chemicals inside the containers may leak out into the water making our waters more toxic.
Originally there were 1700 tonnes of oil aboard and only 1342 tonnes of oil got pumped out. That means 358 tonnes of oil leaked out in to our waters.
There are 403 birds including more than 200 penguins being held at the wild life facility in intensive care. Even one tonne was too much for them.
So, why aren’t we allowed to help with the oil spill? Who was responsible? How did the Rena end up so far off course? Well these are many of the unanswered questions that we need answered – do you have any answers?
Yours sincerely
Katrina
Dear Editor,
I feel heartbroken about the sea. Why did it have to be the sea? What is wrong with the captain? Our beaches are supposed to be a fun place to be. The captain should have thought about this first so this wouldn’t happen. Let me ask the captain a question: Why did you have to take a short cut?
I feel bad about the sea. About 2 or 3 weeks ago I went to Mount Maunganui and on the beach it said CLEAN ME.
I didn’t want the fish to get oily and die. I feel sad even though I don’t like fish but I like going fishing - it’s fun but it’s not fun if there are oily fish and dead fish. I saw One News and a guy told a lame joke about the fish; I don’t think that was funny, it was just dumb. The fish are awesome creatures but not when there are drenched in oil.
There are 4000 volunteers that helped to clean up which is fantastic but now we have to worry about the containers. Eighty-eight containers were lost over board and some containers have dangerous goods on board. Let’s hope the salvors can get all the containers unloaded safely and we, the fish and people of Tauranga can get our beach back again.
Yours sincerely
Clinton
Dear Editor
My main concern about the Rena oil spill is its effect on life –the fish, the birds and the people who rely on fishing for food. The spill means no fishing, no swimming.
The birds are getting coated with oil and that is sad. The beaches were saturated in oil but we have managed to clean up most of it. You can’t walk around the Mount without seeing people trying to rescue birds that are coated in oil or see oil “hanging” from rocks. My uncle found and rescued a seal saturated in oil.
My dad, sister and I walked down the Papamoa beach and didn’t see any oil. The next day we went to the Mount and there were tonnes of bags of oil, scooped up by volunteers, piled up on top of each other.
My plea is that the oil is cleaned up as soon as possible by as many people who are good enough to do it. Come on Tauranga!
Kind regards
Troy
Dear Editor
Have you ever tried helping with the oil spill off the coast of Tauranga? Well if you haven’t I bet you haven’t seen how terrible it is, it’s revolting and I am absolutely disgusted.
It’s fantastic that people are helping but what could we do to remove it more quickly. We need help to take drastic measurement. We need to help the wildlife population survive this catastrophe. We can’t wait any longer-if we do we might not have any wildlife left. Why are people’s offers of help getting turned down? When they want to help? why…..why is this? It is a disgrace!
We need that help, we need to take a stand, we need to save our wildlife and our beaches NOW! So what is being said by the people in charge is that we should just sit around and let our animals die and our beaches get destroyed! NO I am not prepared to do that because I care enough that we won’t have enough animals in our oceans and on our beaches.
If we don’t take action who knows what will happen? Let the people help- it is our problem too.
Yours sincerely
Mercedes
Dear Editor,
I think it’s a dangerous thing for children to be around oil, especially dried oil, because they could eat it then get really sick or even die. I think parents should do their best to keep themselves and their children off the beach so that the workers can do what they need to do to make our beaches safe.
If we don’t keep our children off the beach it will not be fresh air blowing in our faces - it will smell like a dump and look like one too. Every time you take a step you will be standing on dead stuff because you are not trying hard to keep your children off the beach. The reasons why I’m telling you about this is so that we can have a safer environment.
I think it is a bad idea for the penguins to go back into the waters because the containers could fall off and hurt them.
Kind regards
Khan
Dear Editor
I am disgusted about the oil spilling from the Rena - what is the captain trying to do - kill all the wildlife?
I love fishing. I do not want the fish to die because of some foolish captain. If the fish have oil on them, and the birds eat the fish, then the birds will die.
When I was at Maketu, I saw seagulls covered in oil from head to toe even in their eyes. When you take parent birds away to be cleaned, who is going to take care of the babies?
Do not get me started on the beaches; they are coated in oil. At Maketu, as my brother and I walked along the beach we picked up a big sack of oil. We did not even pick up all the oil we saw because the bag was too small and it got worse down the beach.
Despite all the hard work of volunteers, will Maketu ever really be the same?
What’s to stop this from happening again?
Yours sincerely
Tyler
Dear Editor
My biggest worry with the Rena disaster is the oil. No tourist will want to come see our lovely beach now ruined. What if all the sea life died off all around the Bay of Plenty?
Please keep children and parents off the beach because the oil is toxic and could harm them. Look at the birds - they died because of the oil. What about the toxic containers with chemicals which will do a lot of damage to the wild life? What about the Rena with the huge crack in it? What if that snaps then it will leak more oil in to the sea and I think we’ve got enough oil in the sea. Are you telling us the truth on TV and in the newspapers about the Rena?
What are our people doing now? They are cleaning up our beach so we can have a summer holiday. Have you ever been to Papamoa and heard no bird song? Well the oil has wiped that out. Please get the oil out of here.
Yours sincerely
Flynn
Dear Editor
The oil started to pollute the sea we swim in when the Rena crashed into the Astrolabe Reef at 2:20 am on the 5th of October. What are we doing about it?
The volunteers are doing a fantastic job cleaning it up. They are cleaning up the beaches with shovels and safety gear and other gear. There are lots of volunteers helping and even the army is helping because they are cleaning up somebody’s mess. But whose fault is it? Is it the captain’s, the crew or the co-captain? Whoever’s fault it is, they should stand up and tell us the truth.
Because of that huge incident there is a lot of oil on innocent wildlife all because of the Rena. I have seen a lot of dead birds that have been hit by cars and shot by people but not ones that have been covered in oil.
There have been 88 containers that have fallen of the Rena. If one of the containers containing highly flammable chemicals fell off, it might blow up! What would happen then? Will the sea life all die? What if one of containers was hit by a small boat or if it drifted inland and hit someone who was swimming at the Mount? Then what would we do?
Kind regards
Ziarena
Dear Editor
Have you made an effort to try to help with the clean-up our local community has to complete after the Rena ran aground.
Yes, it may be a hard job but it would be worth it to have our beaches clean again and our wildlife free to roam in and on a pristine coastline.
If you have been down to the beach and really seen what state it is in for yourself, you would understand how upset I am. I have noticed when some people have offered to help with the clean-up, they have been turned down. Why is this?
I have been down to the beach and I have seen dead animals before but not dead carcases covered in oil! It is the most devastating sight I have ever seen.
So if you know what I am talking about I suggest that we take action - if there was ever a time that our community needed your help it is now. Do it for the animals; do it for Tauranga.
Yours sincerely
Trinity
Dear Editor
My main concern with the Rena disaster is the environment. All the people who fish won’t be able to go fishing or enjoy nice fresh fish again because the fish could be toxic and clogged up with oil. Birds are affected too; at least 1,300 birds have been killed and the others feed on the fish which could be poisoned.
People are affected in other ways. No swimming for a while or no children making sandcastles on the beach.
Eighty-eight containers have fallen of the Rena - eleven have deadly goods on board. What could they do to the environment?
I climbed Mauao and I could see the ship and the oil all around the sea. As we were going down, we went through a track (but you weren’t allowed to go on the beach) and we saw oil everywhere. We saw a volunteer roll up a ball of oil and throw it - what if it gets in his lungs and kills him or worse still, someone else’s lungs?
I’ve got a lot of questions. How are they going to take the ship off the reef? Will it sink or will it not? How are they going to find the containers that have sunk? How long will it be before we can truly enjoy the beaches?
Yours sincerely
Malcolm
Dear Editor
Over a hundred containers have fallen off the Rena - 88 have been found, 29 are still missing. We need to find all the containers before they just sink to the bottom of the sea, rust and kill sea life.
I strongly believe that the number one priority should be to take all the containers off the Rena before they get the remaining oil off and before it snaps in two. Do we really know what’s in the containers? Are the papers telling the truth? Do the salvors know what is in them? There could be harmful chemicals or flammable things that could kill sea life or even blow the whole thing up.
A few weeks ago I heard that a family had all their furniture and lots of other household good in the containers and I’m sure they would like them back by now. There was even a car in one of the containers worth tens of thousands of dollars. Although these aren’t as critical as the dangerous goods, for these families life is on hold.
In conclusion I would like to reiterate that we need to get all the containers off the ship as soon as possible.
Yours sincerely
Manaaki
Dear Sir/ Madam
All because of a silly choice, the Rena grounding has cost us millions of dollars and the lives of many birds and animals, not to mention the damage to the beautiful Astrolabe Reef. And what about the damage to the beautiful Mayor Island?
How are we going to clean up Mayor Island without further toxicity of the wildlife reserve? What will we use to remove the 10 tonnes of oil expected to wash up on the coastline? There are over eleven types of native birds living there, including the Pied Shag which dives for fish and will easily get covered in oil.
I wish to strongly state that we must all try to find a way to reverse this disaster and get our wildlife and scenery back to its former glory.
Yours sincerely
Petra
Dear Sir
I think it is dangerous that parents are letting their little children run around on the beach where there is oil washed up from the sea. I recently went to the beach and stood on the sand dunes and I saw a parent letting her little children run around. I think people should just let the volunteers do what they can do to tidy up our beaches then everyone can get back to feeling the nice sand running through their toes as they hit the beach. They will be able to feel the cool wind blowing in their face as they run towards the warm water without worrying about all the containers or finding dead sea life washed up on the beaches, drenched in oil.
I am telling you this so we can have our volunteers clean up our beaches so we can have a safer environment.
What do you think about this?
Yours sincerely
Shaniqua
Dear Sir/Madam
We are a city that prides itself on its clean beaches, but that has been ruined by a captain and his crew who were not paying enough attention to their surroundings. People have been so focused on the oil that we have forgotten about the containers.
Eighty-eight containers have fallen off the RENA, maybe even more. Some of them contain hazardous substances, even one that blows up on contact with water. Would you like to go swimming with containers that could blow you to pieces? I know I wouldn’t. Already twenty-nine containers have gone missing; maybe the government should legislate that trackers must be placed on the containers, especially the hazardous ones.
Apparently the RENA was three quarters full when it hit the Astrolabe Reef, but it looked to me like it was way too full. Maybe there should be an investigation into how many containers the oil ships should carry? Also they were bolted together and tied down, why then did they come loose and fall off? I thought that they were stronger then that. There should be an investigation into that as well too.
In conclusion there should be an investigation into how many containers the oil ships should carry and why the ties and bolts came loose. The government should do more about the containers and should try to track them.
Zane
No comments:
Post a Comment